Evidence Log · E-V99-093
Elizondo recounts Socorro, including other motorists, an explosion-like sound and a separate white butane-tank-shaped object, and compares Zamora's oval object to the 2004 Nimitz Tic Tac
UnverifiedSecondhand2024 (publication) · Attributed narrative and morphology comparison (memoir)
Record
- Date
- 2024 (publication)
- Claim or item
- Elizondo recounts Socorro, including other motorists, an explosion-like sound and a separate white butane-tank-shaped object, and compares Zamora's oval object to the 2004 Nimitz Tic Tac
- Evidence category
- Attributed narrative and morphology comparison (memoir)
- Firsthand?
- No
- Publicly accessible?
- Yes (book)
- Independent corroboration
- Other witnesses unnamed; no established link to Nimitz
- Assessment
- Analogy only; witness leads uncorroborated
- Notes
- Attributed claim by Luis Elizondo in Imminent (2024); chapter/page not yet supplied (Jason worked from a user-supplied paraphrase). Jason notes the propulsion descriptions of the two objects differ. Chunk M (2026-11-12): the leads are in the 1964 Blue Book file SRC-V99-091: p. 16 (Gallegos's butane-tank object, at La Madera, not Socorro), p. 72 (Kies and Kratzer of Dubuque named as witnesses), pp. 111 and 138 (the tourist who told Opal Grinder it flew over his car); Zamora's 'roar, not a blast' is in SRC-V99-090 pp. 9-10. The Tic Tac comparison remains analogy.
- Linked case IDs
- CASE-025
Why this grade
UnverifiedSecondhand From the Evidence Log's Assessment ("Analogy only; witness leads uncorroborated"), and Firsthand? ("No"). Grade rules.